How to Write an Evidence-Based Practice Paper

NURSING & HEALTH PAPERS All Homework Solutions · expert essay, research and dissertation help

An evidence-based practice paper asks you to show how research, clinical expertise and patient preferences come together to answer a real clinical question.

Evidence-based practice (EBP) papers are central to nursing and allied health programmes. They test whether you can move from a problem observed in practice to a well-supported recommendation for change. The format varies between programmes — some follow a named EBP model, others a set template — but the core steps are consistent. This guide walks through them in the order they usually appear in the paper.

Start with a clinical problem

EBP papers begin with a genuine practice issue: falls on a ward, pressure injuries, catheter-associated infections, delayed pain management, patient education gaps. Describe the problem, its setting and why it matters, using local data or published figures where possible. A clearly defined problem makes every later step easier.

Stuck on your assignment? Our expert writers can help.

Get help →

Frame a focused clinical question

Convert the problem into a structured question, most commonly using PICO or PICOT: population, intervention, comparison, outcome and time. A focused question determines your search terms and inclusion criteria.

“In adult surgical inpatients (P), does hourly intentional rounding (I) compared with standard care (C) reduce falls (O) over a three-month period (T)?”

Search the literature systematically

Describe your search strategy so a reader could repeat it: databases searched (for example CINAHL, PubMed/MEDLINE, Cochrane Library), keywords and subject headings, Boolean operators, date limits and inclusion and exclusion criteria. Explain how many results you found and how you narrowed them to the final set of studies. A simple flow diagram helps.

Rank the evidence by level

EBP papers expect you to recognise that some study designs provide stronger evidence than others. Systematic reviews and meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials sit at the top of most hierarchies, followed by individual trials, cohort and case-control studies, qualitative studies, and expert opinion. Identify the level of each source you use.

Level Typical design
I Systematic review or meta-analysis of RCTs
II Well-designed randomised controlled trial
III Controlled trial without randomisation
IV Cohort or case-control studies
V–VII Descriptive, qualitative studies, expert opinion

Different models number levels differently; follow the one your programme uses.

Appraise the evidence critically

Higher-level evidence is not automatically good evidence. Use a recognised appraisal tool, such as a CASP checklist or your programme’s preferred framework, to judge each study’s validity, results and relevance. Consider sample size, bias, attrition, measurement and how closely the setting resembles yours. Summarise appraisals in an evidence table rather than describing each study at length.

Synthesise what the evidence shows

Bring the studies together. Where do they agree, where do they conflict and why? How strong is the overall body of evidence for your intervention? Synthesis is where many papers fall short — they appraise studies one by one but never state what the evidence, taken together, supports.

Integrate clinical expertise and patient preferences

EBP is more than research evidence. Discuss how clinical expertise and patient values affect the recommendation. An intervention that works in trials may be impractical with current staffing, or unacceptable to some patients. Showing awareness of these factors demonstrates mature clinical judgement.

Address ethical and practical considerations

Recommending a practice change has consequences for patients and staff. Consider issues such as patient consent and autonomy, equity of access, cost, training needs and potential unintended effects. An intervention that reduces one risk may increase another — for example, increased monitoring may disturb sleep. Brief discussion of these considerations shows that your recommendation has been thought through beyond the evidence table.

Recommend a practice change

State your recommendation clearly and link it directly to the evidence. Be specific about what should change, for whom and how. If the evidence is weak or mixed, a pilot or further evaluation may be a more honest recommendation than full implementation.

Plan implementation using a model

Many programmes ask how you would implement the change. Using a recognised EBP or change model — such as the Iowa Model, the Johns Hopkins model, ACE Star, or Lewin’s change theory — gives your plan structure. Address stakeholders, education, resources, barriers and facilitators, and a realistic timeline.

Barriers matter

Identifying likely barriers, such as staff resistance or workload, and how to overcome them often earns as much credit as the recommendation itself.

Define how you will evaluate the change

Explain how success will be measured: which outcome, how it will be collected, over what period and compared with what baseline. Evaluation closes the EBP cycle and shows that the change is accountable rather than assumed to work.

Follow the format and referencing rules

Most nursing programmes require APA style, and many specify headings and section order. Check the rubric carefully, use current sources (often within the last five to seven years, unless a source is seminal), and make sure every claim about evidence is referenced accurately.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • A clinical question too broad to search effectively.
  • A search strategy that cannot be reproduced.
  • Describing studies one by one without synthesising them.
  • Treating the highest evidence level as automatically the best evidence.
  • Recommendations stronger than the evidence supports.
  • No plan for evaluating whether the change worked.