How to Write a Philosophy Paper
A philosophy paper is an argument. Its job is to defend a clear thesis with reasons, take objections seriously and do it all in language plain enough that every step can be checked.
Students arriving in philosophy courses often write essays the way they would in other subjects: surveying what different thinkers said, adding some opinion and concluding that the question is complex. Philosophy instructors are looking for something more focused. They want to see you take a position on a narrow question and defend it rigorously. This guide explains how.
Understand what a philosophy paper is
A philosophy paper is not a report on the history of ideas or a summary of the reading. It is an attempt to show that a specific claim is true or false, or that an argument succeeds or fails, using careful reasoning. Exposition of other philosophers’ views is necessary, but it serves your argument. A paper that only explains views, however accurately, is incomplete.
Stuck on your assignment? Our expert writers can help.
Narrow the question
Philosophy rewards depth over breadth. “Is free will compatible with determinism?” is too big for a short paper. “Does Frankfurt’s counterexample show that moral responsibility does not require the ability to do otherwise?” is manageable. Focus on a single argument, objection or distinction that you can examine thoroughly in the space available.
Read the primary texts closely
Good philosophy papers rest on accurate understanding of the texts. Read the assigned readings more than once: first for the overall argument, then slowly to identify the key claims, definitions and moves. Note where the author distinguishes terms carefully, as these distinctions often matter for your argument. Secondary sources can help, but do not let a commentator’s summary replace your own reading of the original.
State a clear thesis early
Tell the reader in the first paragraph what you will argue and how. A good thesis is specific and contestable.
Vague: “This paper will discuss utilitarianism and its strengths and weaknesses.”
Clear: “I argue that the demandingness objection does not defeat act utilitarianism, because it relies on an intuition the utilitarian has independent reason to reject.”
Philosophy papers do not need suspense. Signposting your argument helps the reader evaluate it.
Explain the relevant views charitably
Before criticising a view, explain it in its strongest form — the principle of charity. If your objection works only against a weak version of an argument, it is not much of an objection. Explain key terms, reconstruct arguments clearly, and where useful, set out premises and conclusion in numbered form so their structure is visible.
Reconstruct arguments step by step
Setting an argument out in standard form makes it easier to evaluate. Identify each premise and the conclusion, and check whether the conclusion follows. Then ask which premise is most open to challenge. Many good papers focus on showing that one premise is false or unsupported.
P1. If an action is morally required, it must be possible to perform it.
P2. Some actions utilitarianism requires are psychologically impossible for most people.
C. Therefore, utilitarianism requires actions that are not morally required.
Develop your own argument
Your contribution might be an objection to an argument, a defence of a view against an objection, a counterexample, a distinction that resolves an apparent conflict, or a new argument for a position. Whatever form it takes, it should be clearly identifiable as your own work, and it should be developed with reasons rather than asserted.
Raise and answer objections
Strong philosophy papers anticipate the best objections to their thesis and respond to them. Choose the most serious objection, state it fairly and reply. Ignoring obvious objections suggests you have not thought the issue through; addressing them shows confidence in your argument.
Objection and reply
One well-developed objection and reply is worth more than several dismissed in a sentence each.
Use examples and thought experiments carefully
Examples make abstract points concrete, and thought experiments are standard philosophical tools. Make sure each example illustrates exactly the point you intend and that it does not rely on features irrelevant to your argument. When using famous thought experiments, explain them briefly rather than assuming the reader remembers the details.
Write plainly and precisely
Philosophy values clarity. Use short sentences, define technical terms, and use the same word consistently for the same concept — switching between “belief”, “opinion” and “view” for variety can suggest you mean different things. Avoid rhetorical flourishes and grand claims. The first person (“I will argue”) is normal and encouraged in philosophy.
Plan before you write
Outline the structure of your argument before drafting: thesis, exposition, argument, objection, reply and conclusion. Check that each section serves the thesis and that the argument proceeds in a logical order. Many instructors suggest writing a short version of the whole argument in a single paragraph; if you cannot, the argument is not yet clear enough to write the paper.
Quote sparingly and cite properly
Use quotations only when the exact wording matters, for example when interpreting a contested passage. Otherwise, paraphrase accurately. Cite primary texts using the standard editions and page or section numbers expected in your course, and reference secondary literature consistently.
Conclude by restating what you have shown
Summarise your argument and state what you have established, and perhaps what remains open. Do not overstate. If you have shown that one objection to a view fails, do not conclude that the view is true. Precise claims about what your paper achieves are part of philosophical rigour.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Surveying many views without defending a thesis.
- Attacking a weak version of an argument.
- Relying on dictionary definitions of contested concepts.
- Appeals to authority or popularity instead of reasons.
- Ignoring the most obvious objection.
- Ornate prose that obscures the argument.
