How to Answer a Law Problem Question

ESSAY WRITING GUIDES All Homework Solutions · expert essay, research and dissertation help

Law problem questions give you a set of facts and ask you to advise the parties. The skill being tested is not knowing the law in the abstract, but applying it precisely to messy facts.

Problem questions appear in almost every law module, from contract and tort to criminal and public law. Students who know the material well still lose marks by writing essays about the law instead of advice about the facts, or by missing issues hidden in the scenario. The method below — often taught as IRAC or a variation of it — gives a reliable structure for answering any problem question clearly.

Read the facts at least twice

Read the scenario once for an overview, then again slowly, annotating as you go. Every fact is usually there for a reason: dates, words spoken, relationships between parties, the order of events. Underline facts that suggest legal issues and note which area of law each one raises. Pay attention to who you are asked to advise, as this shapes your answer.

Stuck on your assignment? Our expert writers can help.

Get help →

Identify all the issues

Issue-spotting is a core skill. List every legal issue the facts raise, for each party. A single scenario might involve formation of a contract, misrepresentation and remedies, or several different possible offences. Missing an issue costs marks that excellent analysis elsewhere cannot recover, so take time before writing to make a complete list.

Use a clear structure: IRAC

For each issue, follow a consistent structure.

Step What to do
Issue State the legal question raised by the facts
Rule Set out the relevant law with authority
Application Apply the rule to the specific facts
Conclusion State the likely outcome on that issue

Variations such as ILAC or CLEO follow the same logic. Use whichever your module teaches.

State the issue precisely

Frame each issue as a specific legal question tied to the facts. “Contract law” is not an issue. “Whether Amira’s email of 3 March constituted an acceptance of Ben’s offer, given that it introduced a new delivery term” is. Precise issues keep your answer focused and show the marker you understand what is at stake.

State the rule with authority

Explain the relevant legal rule clearly and support it with authority: legislation, leading cases and, where relevant, academic commentary. Cite cases accurately and concisely. You do not need to recount the full facts of every case; state the principle it establishes. Where the law is uncertain or contested, say so, as this often becomes the heart of your analysis.

Spend most of your words on application

Application is where most marks are earned and where most answers are weakest. Show how the rule applies to the specific facts, step by step. Compare and distinguish the facts from leading cases. Where the facts are ambiguous, consider both interpretations and their consequences.

Weak: “The rule in the leading case applies here, so there is a valid contract.”

Stronger: “Unlike the claimant in the leading case, Ben received the email but did not read it until after he had sold the goods. Whether acceptance was effective therefore depends on whether communication is complete on receipt during business hours.”

Reach a conclusion on each issue

After applying the law, state a conclusion: what the likely outcome is, and how confident you are. Courts sometimes go either way; it is acceptable to say an outcome is uncertain if you explain why and which result is more likely. Avoid ending an issue without any conclusion, as advice that does not advise is incomplete.

Consider defences and remedies

Once liability is established, consider what defences might be available and what remedies the claimant could seek. Many problem questions are designed so that a party appears liable until a defence is considered. Remedies — damages, injunctions, rescission, sentencing outcomes — are often worth substantial marks and are frequently forgotten.

Organise the answer logically

Structure your answer by party, by issue, or chronologically, whichever makes the analysis clearest. Use headings to guide the marker. Start with the most significant issue or the one that logically comes first — for example, whether a contract exists before whether it was breached. Keep a brief introduction and avoid lengthy general essays on the area of law.

Do not invent facts, but note missing ones

Work with the facts given. If an important fact is missing, say what difference it would make: “If Carla knew of the defect, the claim would be stronger because…”. Do not create new facts to make the problem easier. Identifying what further information you would need is a useful sign of practical legal thinking.

Write concisely in a professional tone

Write as if advising a client or senior colleague: clear, concise and direct. Avoid casual language and unnecessary background. Use the correct legal terminology, but explain your reasoning so that the logic is visible. Reference according to your institution’s legal citation style.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Writing an essay on the law instead of applying it.
  • Missing issues or parties.
  • Reciting case facts at length instead of the principle.
  • Stating rules without authority.
  • Forgetting defences and remedies.
  • No conclusion on individual issues.